top of page
  • Black Instagram Icon
  • Black Facebook Icon

Review: The Trumpet of the Swan at The Regent Theatre

8 minutes ago
3 min read

Review by Greg Gorton


The Trumpet of the Swan is Opera Australia’s most pseudo-experimental piece for the 2026 season. It is a beautiful, energetic work that is perfect for introducing orchestras and musical theatre to younger audiences. Unfortunately, due to OA’s lack of faith in this work, it is difficult to recommend to families who must ask “is this worth the money?”


The Trumpet of The Swan isn’t exactly what most of us would agree to be “opera”. However, as the CEO of OA says, “At its heart, opera is storytelling through music and drama.” This work, first commissioned in 2008, is one of borderline pantomime, but with a constant orchestra backing, and just enough dance to make you wonder if it also shouldn’t be considered ballet. This combination of performing arts is a beautiful experience.


The plot is taken from E.B. White’s story of the same name, and the libretto consists mostly of direct edits from the work. Bert LaBonté’s narrator draws us into this story, with a voice well-suited to those movies and shows of our childhoods. While LaBonté narrates, each character takes their lines, dances their parts, and brings to life the story with optimistic enthusiasm.

The most compelling aspect of this show is the music. Originally composed by Jason Robert Brown and performed superbly here by Orchestra Victoria, it is the music of Looney Tunes and early Disney films, played light and full of whimsy. The orchestra sits on stage, with the action in front of them, but the line between instrumentalists and actors is sometimes blurred in entertaining ways.


While the music and libretto are impossible to criticise, both in that they are brilliant and easy to speak about, it is not the same with the performances themselves.

Not to be mistaken here, the performers were all quite skilled and some were as brilliant as you could possibly ask for. 


Ben Mingay as Father Swan (and others) fully grasps the caricaturisation required to garner as many laughs as possible without suggesting that his characters should be completely dismissed. Father’s arrogance is not evil, and the love he feels washes over the audience with intensity.


The dancing of Arjun Tiwari as the mute Louis-the-swan is captivating and, I have no idea how, extremely swan-like. There is a grace, but an awkward one, and a strength within weakness.

While these two stand out, all performers are amazing. From the all-suffering mother played by Marney McQueen, to Scout Hook’s conventional Serena, these actors and dancers find ways to create individual characters that may be laughed at, loved, and cheered for. Many of the performers are still students in Musical Theatre, and I think this shows in what good hands Melbourne’s arts world will be in as long as it is properly supported.


The core concept of this production is brilliant, and to recast it would be a sin. The unforgivable element of this show, however, hangs like an ugly shadow over the entire night.

Opera Australia didn’t believe in it.


Director Tyran Parke admits that it was “a rehearsal period measured in days rather than weeks”, and that statement informs everything. Actors read off scripts like it is a moved reading, there is little-to-no choreography between orchestra and dancer, and there were multiple occasions in which the (very talented) lighting operator had to make on-the-fly decisions to accommodate actions on stage. Props and costumes consisted of “first idea not best idea” choices, and little chemistry could be developed between any performers.


You could not fault the wider creative decisions made. You could fault the lack of chance to present them fully. With proper resources, based on what could be experienced of these core ideas, The Trumpet of the Swan would have been THE Opera Australia event in Melbourne this year. Creative ideas, enthusiastic performers, and a unique bedrock from which to work from - perhaps we need more of this, and a few less years of “Carmen” and “La Traviata”.


I truly, with all my heart, hope more experiences, like The Trumpet of the Swan, are encouraged. More importantly, I hope that the company looks at these works not as “a cheap addition” but a chance to really stand out at a time when opera is seen as too stodgy and expensive to attend.

Image Supplied
Image Supplied

bottom of page