Review: A Beautiful Noise at Sydney Lyric Theatre
Review by Michelle Fisher
Let's be honest, with songs like 'Forever in Blue Jeans,' 'Sweet Caroline' and 'Song Sung Blue,' it would be hard for a night at A Beautiful Noise: The Neil Diamond Musical not to be a hit. As a die-hard Diamond fan, I have to admit that this is not the first time I have seen the show but I was definitely excited to say 'hello again' and get back deep into the world of some of my favourite songs. I knew I was going to love this jukebox musical pretty much no matter what they did, and the audience on opening night was definitely with me in that sentiment. Making the night even better was that this great song list was performed by such a fantastic cohort of Australian (and international) talent. The show is not perfect but it definitely delivers a great night of entertainment.
Will Swenson, who originated the role of the younger Neil Diamond on Broadway and takes on this lead role again in Australia, has the assurance of someone who has had time to settle into a part, develop the character and become extremely comfortable in the role. There’s an ease to the way he moves between the scenes and the songs giving his performance a beautiful air of authenticity. He unquestionably has the voice and the stage presence to carry the evening, however, personally, I was still always aware that I was watching Will Swenson play Neil Diamond. That’s a slightly frustrating thing to say about a performance I enjoyed, but I kept thinking of Jessie Mueller in Beautiful: The Carole King Musical, one of my favourite performances in a show like this. There were stretches of Beautiful when I was so taken with Mueller’s King that I forgot to pay attention to how she was doing it. With Swenson, I could hear the care he’d taken with the voice and see how naturally he handled the demands of the role. I admired the performance throughout. I just never quite got lost in it.
Anthony McCarten’s book opens with an older Diamond, played by Terence Crawford, in a session with his therapist, played by Monica Sayers. The two look back through his lyrics, and the younger Diamond takes us into the memories those songs bring up. What would you hear in a song you wrote decades ago if somebody asked you to read the words back to them? What would you recognise about the person who wrote it? It's a good premise and though it carries the story through, it isn't a particularly strong book and for a man with such an interesting life story, seems at times like a bit of a light trope to tell this story.
For me, the book is too quick to move through the life it has set out to examine. The therapy sessions give Diamond a reason to return to a memory, but I often wanted more time in that memory before we went back to the consulting room or on to the next song. I felt that most in the scenes with his wives. Alana Tranter plays his first wife, Jaye Posner, and there’s so little space given to Jaye that it’s hard to get a sense of what the two were like together before his career began to pull them apart. A little more time with them early on would have made me care more about what happened to them later.
Ashleigh Rubenach really shines as Marcia Murphey, Diamond’s second wife. Marcia also has relatively little material given how significant she is in this part of his life, but Rubenach makes me interested in what she wants out of the relationship almost as soon as she arrives. Her ‘Forever in Blue Jeans’ was a highlight for me. I liked hearing a song so closely associated with Diamond in her voice, and I liked having a moment in which Marcia could tell us what mattered to her. The poignant rendition of “You Don’t bring me Flowers “ depicting the end of their 25year marriage also gives Rubenach a rich moment to show her skills and made me want more of those moments, for both women. She is a standout on the Australian musical theatre scene at the moment and deservedly so.
Visually, this is a lovely production. David Rockwell’s set has the feel of a recording studio in some scenes and a concert stage in others, with the band visible upstage. The lamps were my favourite touch. There’s a warmth to them that suits the more intimate scenes and gives the eye somewhere to rest before the show opens up again. Emilio Sosa’s costumes are equally well suited. They give us a sense of the period as the years move on, and when Diamond gets to the point in his career where he can come out in an outfit that catches the light from practically every seat in the house, the costumes are every bit as dazzling as you’d hope.
The Australian ensemble is excellent. It’s easy with a catalogue this familiar to focus on whoever is singing lead, but I found myself watching the dancers even in numbers I’d been looking forward to hearing. Steven Hoggett’s choreography asks a lot of them across the evening, and there’s real pleasure in watching a company work this well together. Nigel Ubrihien and the band deserve every bit as much credit. There’s a fullness to the music when they’re all playing that makes a persuasive case for hearing these songs in a theatre. Some of my favourite stretches of the evening were simply Swenson, the band and a song they could truly show off with.
I left wishing McCarten’s book had been as curious about the people in Diamond’s life as it was about the songs he wrote. I also left thinking how gladly I’d listen to that band play ‘Cracklin’ Rosie’ again and how much fun an evening of Diamond’s highlights had been.
For me, any night where I get to listen to Neil Diamond music is a winner so if the prospect of hearing Diamond’s best songs played this well is what draws you to the Lyric, there’s a great deal to enjoy and you're in for a great night of entertainment.



